However it is well settled that all measures, substantive as well as procedural as are incorporated in the regulations are done so for the efficacious achievement of the object and purpose sought to be achieved by the prohibition. Highly criticising the oral examinations, the author further observed thus:. The Supreme Court explained the earlier judgment thus:. In view of the challenge which has been laid in my view, this prohibition would required to be examined in the light of the principles which have been laid down by the courts so far as challenges to delegated legislations are concerned. It was further observed that the oral interview test was undoubtedly not a very satisfactory test for assessing and evaluating the capacity and calibre of candidate, but in the absence of a better test for measuring personal characteristics and traits, the oral interview test must, at the present stage, be regarded as not irrational or irrelevant though it is subjective and based on first impression, its result is influenced by many uncertain factors and it is capable of abuse. M courses in 22 departments each year, excluding the autonomous All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, which has an intake of 11 students spread over 3 years.
It was held that what constitutes fair play depends on the facts and circumstances relating to a particular given situation. I find that the orders relied on relate to entrance exams and consequently cannot govern the adjudication in the present case. While a written examination has certain distinct advantages over the interview-test there are yet no written tests which can evaluate a candidate’s initiative, alertness, resourcefulness, dependableness, cooperativeness, capacity for clear and logical presentation, effectiveness, in discussion, judgment, ability to make decision, ability to lead, intellectual and moral integrity. A candidate is allowed to appear in the final theory examination only after undergoing the training successfully and upon certification by the hospital. To my mind, no parity can be drawn between such testing and the conventional interview conducted in an office room from behind a desk. The court observed that in view of the fact that the time as spent on each candidate was not more than four minutes and in these circumstances, reserving 50 marks for the interview out of the total of does seem excessive.
Most state medical councils, however, have made it mandatory for practicing physicians, including endocrinologists, to obtain a minimum number of CME credits every year.
It is asserted that a candidate knowing the rules fully and having appeared in the examination cannot challenge the criterion of success or sttaus laid down by the rules. The quiz, conducted at the SAFES Summit in Hyderabadand planned for Dhakais one way of demonstrating the interesting side of endocrinology to trainees.
Even when a surgery is in progress problems may come up where the Surgeon and the Anaesthesist require a snap decision by an expert in the filed of Pathology. The submission is that the assessment by the experts is done objectively. Shri Jagmohan Accordingly, the prayer made by the natboarc in prayers a and b are also rejected.
The Court’s duty lies in preventing arbitrariness and denial of equal opportunity. The first post graduate fellowship program, labeled Doctor of Medicine D. Shri George Fernandes, M. In this behalf, the stipulation is containing such prohibition is to be found in Clause 6. The board has developed and introduced various reforms in the conduct of postgraduate and postdoctoral examinations keeping in view the purpose and process of evaluation.
This time the petitioner demanded her marks as well as the marks obtained in all previous examinations vide a letter dated 24th September, This thesis was also approved in a single attempt entitling the petitioner natboagd appear for the practical examination in terms of Clause 6. Therefore the petitioner’s challenge to the result secured by her is misconceived and also devoid of any factual or material basis.
In these circumstances, it is not possible to ntaboard that the distribution of the marks or the test criterion laid down by the respondents is either arbitrary or irrational. State of Haryana and Ors While noticing that an oral interview test is undoubtedly not a very satisfactory test for assessing and evaluating the capacity and calibre of candidates, it was held that in the absence of any better test for measuring personal characteristics and traits, the oral interview test, ghesis, at the present stage, be regarded as not irrational or irrelevant.
There are several examinations relating to specialisations wherein the marks of the candidate are not disclosed.
This can be done by attending approved CME programs, delivering talks at designated meetings, or publishing in indexed journals. In accordance with the requirement of Article 19 of the Constitution of India as well as Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,an obligation is cast on several public authorities to provide information and maintain all records consistent with its operational requirements, dual catalogued, index and published at regular prescribed intervene.
For that matter the time taken by the candidates in an oral examination is far less than that in the theory and practical examinations. Again, no such stand has been taken by the respondents in the counter affidavit or in the explanation which has been rendered.
It has been vehemently natbooard by Mr. Needless to say this right to information is not an absolute right, but is subject to statutory and constitutional restrictions. sttaus
Endocrinology training in India
Even otherwise, the manner in which the learned single judge had the answer-book of the appellant in General Science paper re-evaluated cannot be justified. Nine DNB residencies are filled each year as well. The respondents are possessed of the power to impose such prohibitions as are necessary for effective conduct of the examination and in public interest. Having been fully aware of the position thereof, the petitioner has participated and taken the examination on all occasions noticed hereinabove.
The number of marks which have to be assigned to the viva voce will depend on the level of the examination and the nature of the specialisation.
However it is well settled that all measures, substantive as well as procedural as are incorporated in the regulations are done so for the efficacious achievement of the object and purpose sought to be achieved by the prohibition.
In any case, issuing such a direction so far as examination already conducted is concerned would serve no fruitful purpose. Many candidates may like to take a chance and pray for re-evaluation of their answer-books.
Welcome To National Board Of Examination
It has been repeatedly held that no orders ought to be made which would have the effect of slackening the standard and would amount to a judicial fiat to control the mode of education and the examining system. As mentioned by us earlier, all that is necessary is that the questions should not be a mere pretence.
Frequent interaction through, both formal and informal contacts, antboard various endocrinology departments, ensures that innovation spread throughout the profession. Not it is true that no record of questions and answers asked and given at the M.